Let Us Do All The Work!

Our Expert Agents Compare and shop for Auto and Home Insurance from over 20 Top National and Regional Insurance carriers to find you the best policy.

Get a Quote Today

Insurance Experts

As your trusted local insurance agency, we’re here to help you shop new for insurance. We make the process effortless and stress-free. When you call, our expert agents will compare policies from over 20 Top National and Regional Carriers to find the perfect fit for you. We know that to compare coverage options, limits, and packages can be overwhelming—so let us do the heavy lifting and help you compare all the details. With the personalized care of a family-owned business and a modern, forward-thinking approach, we combine the best of both worlds: that friendly, local ‘Mom and Pop’ feel, while delivering the expertise and service you deserve.

40+

Years in Business

4 States Served

20+

Insurance Carriers

Life Insurance in Delaware

Compare Options, Right for you

Car Insurance Expert Driving down the road

Auto

Are you tired of paying too much for auto insurance? At our Agency, we help you compare flexible coverage options so you can choose the best fit. By comparing policies from top carriers, our expert agents ensure you receive the best protection at the best price. What’s more, we’ll also work with you to compare different packages and tailor a policy that meets your specific needs, giving you peace of mind without the high costs

Home

Your home is more than just your biggest asset—it’s where memories are made. Therefore, let us help you protect it with the right coverage. In addition, we’ll assist you in comparing policy options, evaluating coverage limits, and even exploring additional endorsements you may not have known you needed. Not all Home policies are the same, However we can help you navigate shopping for the right policy and coverages.

Small Business

Small businesses are the backbone of this country, and we understand just how much your business means to you. We also know that your customers are essential to your success. That’s why we’re here to help you compare a range of insurance policies, taking the stress off your plate. In doing so, we’ll find a plan that’s perfectly tailored to your needs. No matter the size of your business, we offer flexible options to ensure you’re fully covered.

See Why Our Customers Love Us

      EXCELLENT  
   Based on 366 reviews 
    
 
 
 
   
 
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Olesya Sheptytska 
 31 October 2026
 
 
  Great experience with Sheets Insurance Agency. Specifically I am working with Chris Phillips, he is super helpful, very knowledgable, very supportive with many ideas. I just moved to DE and he did a great job assisting me with right insurance according to my needs. Would definitely recommend.
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   arthur hixson 
 30 October 2026
 
 
  My  experience with Sheets was excellent. Chris Phillips answered all of my questions and saved me money on my insurance. I highly recommend Chris.
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   Digital 
 30 October 2026
 
 
  Great experience. Chris knows his stuff. Office staff is excellent.
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   Jeanine Walker 
 20 October 2026
 
 
  Jen is so helpful with all of my questions. She's very attentive to all of my needs. I'll always be grateful for her help and understanding.
Thank you again Jeanine Walker
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   w m 
 13 October 2026
 
 
  Chris was extremely helpful throughout the process of finding insurance. He took the time to explain my options, answer all my questions, and help me find the best coverage for my needs. He made the entire process easy and stress-free, and I really appreciated his professionalism, patience, and excellent customer service. I highly recommend Chris to anyone looking for insurance. Thank you for all your help!