Serving the local Bear, Newark and Middletown communities for over 40 years.

Sheets Insurance Agency specializes in Car, Home, Business, Commercial Auto, and Life Insurance.

About Us

As a full-service locally owned insurance agency, it is our responsibility to find you the protection you need no matter what. We’ll provide you with the best coverage at the best possible price. And if you suffer a loss, we are your first contact. We’ll stand beside you during the process and help to see that you get fair, prompt payment. We try our best to do things quickly. Nothing is more important to us than customer service.

40+

Years in Business

4

States Served

20+

Insurance Carriers

Our Services


Auto Insurance

Paying too much for auto insurance? By offering flexible coverage options and expert service, Sheets Insurance Agency aims to ensure that you receive the best possible protection

Home Insurance

Whether you’re a homeowner or a renter, finding the right insurance coverage for your property is essential in safeguarding against potential risks and uncertainties. Sheets Insurance Agency can assist you in exploring various coverage options and determining the best policy.

Business Insurance

Whether you’re seeking coverage for property, liability, workers’ compensation, or other business-related risks, Sheets Insurance Agency can help you explore the available options and find a policy that aligns with your budget and coverage requirements.



See Why Our Customers Love Us